Can Downloadable Beginner Piano Lessons Really Teach You to Play Piano?

We live in a world of fast food, instant messaging,position my hands for basic mid-keyboard
and virtually instantaneous downloadable musicfingering. My fingers were assigned numbers which
purchases. Is it possible to quickly learn to playcorresponded with white notes surrounding middle
the piano from an online system of beginner pianoC, and I was taught what I needed to learn to
lessons also?play a very simple exercise.
Don't you need a real person to talk you throughSo far, so good.
how to sit at the keyboard and how to hold yourThen I was shown, by example, how to follow
hands? Who is going to watch you and see if yousimple notes from both the bass clef (for the left
are doing everything wrong? Maybe even offerhand) and the treble clef (for the right) to play a
up a few words of encouragement? Or, are yourepeatable phrase, and follow the music. But, I
simply rushing the notes and this is why you aredidn't have adequate instruction, in my opinion, on
getting tripped up?the differences between the two clefs to really
Or maybe, learning to play the musical keyboardallow me to know why I was doing what I was
is like learning to use a computer keyboard,shown to do. This is where a live teacher would
something that millions of people have taughtlikely have been better.
themselves. Using a computer with any kind ofThe next lessons had me playing simple nursery
proficiency is pretty difficult to do by oneself, andrhyme music that anyone can hum, and even
this is done all the time. Could learning to play thecoordinating both hands doing simple passages. I
piano be all that different?wasn't really playing leads with full chord
Well, I have had only a modicum of training on theaccompaniment yet, but I was progressing nicely.
piano, even though I admit to being familiar withLearning as much as I did without any human
music in general, and I have to tell you about my(present) guidance was a revelation, but as I
own experience with a piano learning system Iadmitted above, I am familiar with music. Still, I
found online.believe I would have fared OK, it just would have
I was not shown how to sit up straight on thetaken me a bit longer.
chair or stool, but I WAS instructed on how to